The Search for the Man in the Iron Mask: A Historical Detective Story - Hardcover

Paul Sonnino is professor of history at the University of California Santa Barbara. His books include Louis XIV’s View of the Papacy: 1661–1667, Louis XIV: Mémoires for the Instruction of the Dauphin, Louis XIV and the Origins of the Dutch War, and Mazarin’s Quest: The Congress of Westphalia and the Coming of the Fronde.

Spurred by a decades-long interest, Sonnino delves through well-combed and newly released documents in this attempt to identify the Bastille’s infamous prisoner: the Man in the Iron Mask. Voltaire speculated about him and Alexandre Dumas immortalized him, yet the uncertainty surrounding the identity of the man veiled in black velvet continues to enthrall conspiracy theorists and historical detectives three centuries after his death. With a conversational tone and well-chosen excerpts, Sonnino patiently suggests potential candidates and exposes the flaws in his own early theories as well as those of others, before settling on the figure of Eustache Dauger, a loose-tongued valet who was privy to substantial secrets. Sonnino’s work sheds light on the desperation of ousted English Queen Henrietta Maria and quite intentionally focuses on the influential French Cardinal Mazarin—to conceal Mazarin’s corruption and protect other powerful figures, a particular prisoner remained hidden, his identity scrubbed from documents and his face veiled for the rest of his life. Dauger retains some of his mystery because of a dearth of surviving personal information, but Sonnino’s search allows readers to participate in the fun of unmasking a legendary figure from the era of the Sun King and The Three Musketeers. (Publishers Weekly)

Sonnino is allergic to unsubstantiated assertions and trusts only the historical record. From an impressive range of published and, particularly, archival sources he unearths and marshals facts which point to a lesser personage, someone who moved in high society but was not of it, who would not be missed, probably a valet. He is left with Eustache Dauger, who served Cardinal Mazarin, Fouquet and other notables who had roles in political life and fingers in secret pies. Dauger has been named before, but Sonnino gives the most convincing answer yet to the obvious question: why would Louis take so much trouble to lock up a menial? His answer is that Dauger knew that much of the fortune left by Mazarin which passed to Louis consisted of jewels and paintings acquired at loan-shark prices from Henrietta Maria, Charles I’s widow. If that, together with what he had overheard of the King’s lust to acquire the Spanish Netherlands, were to be revealed, Louis’s policies abroad and good name at home would be in ruins. Sonnino commends his theory because it is backed by the best available evidence. But he also concedes with wry good humour that his man Dauger could be eliminated at any time by the discovery of a vital new piece of information. But until that diary entry or letter turns up, his careful detective work has delivered a most seductive solution to the historical mystery of the man behind the mask. (Times Literary Supplement)

The mere mention of the man in the iron mask brings to mind Alexandre Dumas’ final installment of his Three Musketeers saga and its numerous movie adaptations. It is exciting to contemplate. Who was the Bastille’s most famous prisoner, this man with his face obscured by an iron mask, and what did he do to deserve such a fate? Sonnino’s slim but thoroughly researched book proposes an answer to this mystery. Sonnino spends a fair amount of time dispelling the long-held theories on who the prisoner might have been. All of the tantalizing suspects are out. The captive was not the son of Oliver Cromwell, nor the love child of Anne of Austria, or the twin of Louis XIV. The man turns out to be a valet named Eustache Dauger who knew too much and revealed his secrets to the wrong people. The book really picks up when Sonnino finally gets to Dauger and the conspiracy he found himself a part of. This book will appeal to scholars and researchers. (Historical Novel Society)

In The Search for the Man in the Iron Mask, Paul Sonnino applies his consummate knowledge of the diplomatic and administrative records of the seventeenth-century French monarchy to a mystery dating from 1669: the identity of a prisoner held by the royal government in the utmost secrecy. . . . This is a fascinating book of great erudition that is written with considerable wit, and it will be of much interest to specialists in early modern French history. Indeed, Sonnino offers a model of careful historical research incorporating all of the major Parisian archives and libraries, a host of French departmental and municipal archives, and manuscript repositories in eight countries outside of France. Sonnino’s search for the man in the iron mask may prove to be the definitive statement on the identity of that mysterious prisoner. (H-France Review)

Sonnino ... has used his sources to assemble a highly plausible hypothesis, one which throws down an imposing challenge to historians seeking to advance different candidates or alternative motives for the imprisonment.... Offering an impressive, detailed overview of the murky politics of the years surrounding Mazarin’s death and the arrest and trial of Fouquet, Sonnino leaves no doubt that lots of people had lots to hide, and that the man in the iron mask had stumbled into a political swamp which seeped through the government and court, reaching the crown itself. (French History)

[S]cholars who plan to read the book might skip this [review] to save for themselves the pleasure of having Sonnino, who always writes with verve, lead them through his impressive archival research and decades-long hunt on his own terms.... Sonnino’s sense of people—from the repulsive Mazarin to the hapless Anne of Austria—resonates throughout. True to his theory, Sonnino denies himself some opportunities to draw larger themes, but the less abstemious can find some: the many legacies of Mazarin, the perilous intimacy of valets with their masters, the willingness of some to bend or break the law but not to violate social custom, and the tendency of eighteenth-century political gossip to imagine some kinds of corruption (heterosexual love affairs, hidden pregnancies or twins, or revenge plots) but not others, like that admixture of venality, ambition, and fear so well described here. (Catholic Historical Review)

Sonnino gives us insight into the political intrigues of the 1660s and the sometimes quite unappetizing monetary transactions of Mazarin. This he accomplishes with great virtuosity and the intuition of a master detective. Sonnino has written a very readable and entertaining book. (Historisches Zeitschrift)

I went into this book knowing almost nothing about the story of the Man in the Iron Mask (no, I never even saw the movie) or the world in which he lived. Paul's writing was approachable and great for an 'Iron Mask' novice such as myself. . . . [A]ll in all an interesting read. (Heather Stitches)

The Search for The Man In The Iron Mask should appeal to anyone who loves a good historical puzzle, particularly if you’re a Dumas fan and grew up reading his thrilling adventures as I did. Paul Sonnino’s writing possesses a clarity and dry sense of humor which makes this an illuminating and entertaining read. (By Hook Or By Book)

I've always been a fan of the Man in the Iron Mask history and mythology. Sonnino's take is an interesting angle to take into account. One thing is for sure is that he's done some serious homework. . . .I really enjoyed the devious history that surrounded the wealth and royalty of the time that Sonnio did well to detail and include in his story. Sonnio weaves a creative story from beginning to end with a Tudors kind of reality drama. I requested the book expecting a sort of story tale but got a history lesson instead however it didn't prevent me from enjoying it. (Krissy's Bookshelf Reviews)